ESTHER MENELL'S BLOG

Tag: mothers

WHAT ABOUT SALLY . . .

It was coming across Rory Stewart’s choice description of Boris Johnson as ‘a terrible prime minister and a worse human being’ which prompted me to listen again the other day to his, Rory’s, Desert Island Discs, and this reminded me of something I had never understood, which is why we were always hearing so much about Rory Stewart’s father but never a word about his mother.       

Why am I interested?  Well, Sally and I had been in the same year at  Oxford in what was then a women’s college and met up, fifteen years or so ago, at one of those overnight college get-togethers, particularly memorable because the electricity failed and my expectation of hot cocoa and gossip went for a burton.

But we had been seated next to each other at the evening meal and it was then I learnt that we had sons of much the same age and now that I know how very remarkable Rory already was, she did not make a production of this.  But that was Sally.  She had always been exceptionally well-mannered and discreet. 

St Hilda’s 1954 intake.  Sally, front row, 5th from left.  Me, front row, 2 1/2 from right.

Most of us in that mid-‘50s intake had very quickly paired up, even ganged up, and spent at least as much time talking about ourselves as we did about Chaucer or Milton or whatever;  but Sally, though courteous to all, wasn’t a joiner and, thinking back, the only thing we knew about her home life was that she lived in Wimbledon.   To discover – in a long New Yorker piece which did mention Sally – that her father was Jewish, was a surprise. 

And, hadn’t there also been an earlier husband? I can’t be sure for – with the exception of a couple who had been joined at the hip since day one – none of us actually got married before we went our separate ways. But the pressure to be married, when we were young, led to a lot of false starts.   If you didn’t find a husband then, when would you?  So it wouldn’t be surprising if, like me, she was on her second husband.

Whether or not, I had a hazy memory of a very tall, very English man – an engineer, a builder of bridges, and talk of foreign lands . . .  And any time I thought of Sally, I imagined her leading a Somerset Maugham kind of life in some faraway place.  Not a bad guess, as the one fact that googling ‘Rory Stewart’s mother’ reveals, apart from her full name, is that her son was born in Hong Kong. 

If my attempt to get Rory’s books out of the local library hadn’t failed (see Now What?) no doubt all would have become clear.  As it is, I will always regret that we haven’t seen him in Downing Street over these past few years.  And it remains hard to understand why there has been so much in the media about his father and nothing about his mother.  Can it really be that in this day and age mothers*, including women like Sally who have careers of their own, are still not considered worth mentioning?

*Our year excelled in mothers.  Hugh Grant’s mother is also in that photo (3 rows down and 5 across) and, like Sally and me, she spent her first year living in digs way up the Iffley Road. 

A TICKET TO THE MOON

Talking with a friend of my own age the other day, as we sat on kitchen chairs at either end of her small front garden, I heard, or thought I heard – still not acclimatised to the hearing-aid I should have learnt how to use before lockdown – that her late mother had once bought, and paid real money for, a ticket to the moon . . .   

What else does one need to know about someone than that!

We were talking about mothers.  About being them and having them.  What we know about our own, and what our children and grandchildren know about us.  Not an entirely comfortable subject when you reflect on those long-ago days when your child needed you, wanted only you and, for too short a time, thought everything you said and did a miracle of rightness.

How short a time those glory days lasted! I still remember my son, at a very young age, saying that I would claim an elephant was Jewish, if it was particularly clever.  A wholly justified rebuke.  My Jewishness, until recently, extending no further than often wondering whether someone was or wasn’t. 

Not many years later, his self-assertion took more active form:  overnight, this enthusiastic meat-eater turned vegetarian.  A step guaranteed to disrupt family meals, the bedrock of family life.  And a prelude to his untimely departure.

Of course, every child is different.  Some are less impatient, more hesitant about breaking the ties with home, but each one of us needs to do it eventually, or become that sad creature, the child who never leaves.*

Myself, I took the easy way, as I discover now, rooting through old letters.  I waited till there was distance between myself and my parents, and am ashamed at finding how seldom, now that I was enjoying myself at Oxford, I bothered to write home.   My father’s frequent letters to me ended, almost always, with a plea that I write more often, for my mother’s sake.  Her more laboured efforts (she never became fluent in written English) are more subdued.  She found it harder to bear my neglect.

My son’s way of breaking free was more dramatic, but that only made his return the more wondrous, and I only wish that now, thirty years on, I could cook him his favourite roast-lamb homecoming meal.  But an ocean divides us.

It was a funeral which woke me up to how much parents come to need their children.  Infancy and old age have all too much in common.  I could not see my husband being able to put on the carefully choreographed event from which we had just returned. Who, I asked him, is going to organise my funeral?  His answer was anecdotal.  It seems that when Bach’s wife died, his oldest daughter came to him and asked what they should do about her mother’s funeral. ‘Ask Mama,’ was his answer. 

Of course, primitive peoples – poor people – have always known that the hordes of children whose births they could not, anyway, have avoided are not only going to till the fields but also look after them in their old age.  We, on the other hand, with our 1.7 birth rate, have a bleak future. Which is why I liked the idea of spending my final years becoming acclimatised to dying, among people of my own age, and with help at hand  But no one is going to sign up for even the plushest of care homes for a very long time to come and, with this escape route cut off, I envy my friend, with two grown-up daughters to look after her, whose adventurous mother had hoped to fly to the moon.

My own mother’s ambition could not have been more different.  She longed not for an unknown future, but for the familiar past:  to speak her own language, to see the friends of her youth . . .                               

My mother (right) with a friend, some time in the 1920s

Whether I will ever see my son again remains in the lap of the gods.  But, whatever happens, whoever comes into this house when both I and my husband have left it, there, among the debris, they will find my seventeen-year-old mother’s diary, trapped for ever in fading Russian script.  

Unable and unwilling to read it, I will never know what she was like then, any more than my son will know what I was like before I became his mother.  And that is how it should be, or so it seems to me.   Parents aren’t, like friends, for knowing. 

*With apologies to the many young people who cannot now afford to leave home.